Allianz

Trade
CONTACT US
Search
A person is typing calculator.

Bank Guarantees, Surety Bonds & TCI: Choosing the Right B2B Trade Protection 

Updated on 28 May 2025

In the dynamic arena of global trade, managing risk is paramount. Expanding into new markets or partnering with unfamiliar buyers often requires assurances beyond a simple contract. Financial instruments like Bank Guarantees (BGs) have long served to protect sellers and project owners. But are they always the best fit? 

Today’s B2B landscape demands a nuanced approach. Understanding BGs is crucial, but so is knowing their alternatives – particularly Surety Bonds and Trade Credit Insurance (TCI). This guide explores these key instruments, helping you choose the right solution to trade with confidence. 

 

Summary

Key Takeaways

  • Bank Guarantees (BGs): A bank's promise to cover a party's obligations, offering strong security but often requiring collateral and impacting credit lines. Primarily used for specific, high-value transactions. 
  • Surety Bonds: A three-party agreement where an insurer (Surety) guarantees performance/payment to an obligee, often a more capital-efficient alternative to BGs, especially in construction and service contracts. 
  • Trade Credit Insurance (TCI): Protects a seller's entire portfolio of accounts receivable against non-payment, ideal for ongoing trade and managing broad credit risk. 
  • Choosing Wisely: The best tool (BG, Surety, or TCI) depends on the specific need – project performance, payment assurance, or overall A/R protection – and factors like cost, collateral, and scope. 

What Is a Bank Guarantee (BG)? 

A Bank Guarantee is a promise issued by a bank or financial institution to cover a debtor's financial or performance obligations if the debtor fails to fulfill their contractual commitments. Essentially, the bank steps in, shifting a specific risk from one party (the beneficiary) to itself. 

BGs are widely used globally, especially in industries like construction, infrastructure projects, and large-scale manufacturing. They act as a critical safety net, enabling companies to secure contracts, enter new markets, or build trust with new partners. 

Common Types & Uses of Bank Guarantees in B2B 

BGs are versatile and address various needs: 

  • Performance Guarantees: Assure one party (often a project owner) that another party (a contractor) will fulfill its contractual obligations. 
  • Advance Payment Guarantees (APGs): Protect a buyer who makes an upfront payment to a seller, ensuring the buyer can recover the payment if the seller doesn't deliver the goods or services. 
  • Bid/Tender Guarantees: Assure a project owner that a bidding contractor, if awarded the contract, will actually sign it and provide any required performance bonds. 
  • Warranty Guarantees: Secure the performance of a product or service after completion, covering defects during a warranty period. 
  • Financial Guarantees: Assure payment will be made. 

BGs can also be: 

  • Unconditional (On-Demand): The bank pays the beneficiary upon a simple written demand, without needing proof of default. Highly secure for the beneficiary but riskier for the debtor. 
  • Conditional: The beneficiary must provide evidence of the debtor's default according to specific conditions before the bank pays. 

The Pros and Cons of Bank Guarantees 

Advantages: 

  • High Confidence: Issued by banks, they carry significant weight and trust. 
  • Liquidity: Can allow buyers to avoid large upfront deposits. 
  • Market Access: Facilitate entry into new markets or high-value deals. 

Limitations: 

  • Cost & Collateral: BGs can be expensive, and banks often require significant cash collateral or assets, tying up the applicant's capital and reducing their available credit lines. 
  • Complexity & Time: The application and drafting process can be lengthy and complex. 
  • Drafting Risks: Poorly worded guarantees can lead to disputes or non-enforceability. Legal expertise is vital. 
  • Limited Scope: Usually cover specific financial or performance aspects, not broader risks like political issues or quality disputes. 

Exploring the Alternatives: Surety Bonds & Trade Credit Insurance 

Given the limitations of BGs, B2B companies should consider powerful alternatives: 

1. Surety Bonds: The Specialist Alternative 

A Surety Bond is a three-party agreement: 

  • Principal: The party obligated to perform (e.g., a contractor). 
  • Obligee: The party receiving the guarantee (e.g., a project owner). 
  • Surety: An insurance company (like Allianz Trade) that guarantees the Principal’s obligations to the Obligee. 

Bank Guarantee vs. Surety Bond: While they often cover similar needs (Performance, Advance Payment, Bid), Surety Bonds offer key advantages: 

  • Capital Efficiency: Surety Bonds typically do not require 100% collateral. They are underwritten based on the Principal's financial strength and track record, freeing up capital and credit lines. 
  • Specialist Expertise: Sureties possess deep industry knowledge (especially in construction) and often provide pre-qualification and project support, adding value beyond just the guarantee. 
  • Claims Handling: Sureties often investigate claims more thoroughly, potentially protecting the Principal from unfair calls often associated with on-demand BGs. 

Surety is often the preferred instrument for performance-related obligations, especially in construction and long-term service contracts. 

2. Trade Credit Insurance (TCI): Portfolio Payment Protection 

As your original article noted, TCI is another vital tool. Unlike BGs or Surety (which are usually transaction/project-specific), Trade Credit Insurance covers your entire portfolio of accounts receivable against the risk of non-payment due to buyer insolvency or protracted default. It's ideal for businesses with ongoing sales and a need for broad, cost-effective credit risk protection. 

BG vs. Surety vs. TCI: Making the Right Choice 

The best tool depends on the specific risk you need to mitigate: 

1. Use a Bank Guarantee when: 

  • The beneficiary insists on a bank instrument. 
  • It's a pure financial guarantee and Surety isn't applicable. 
  • You have strong banking relationships and available collateral/credit lines. 

2. Use a Surety Bond when: 

  • You need Performance, Bid, or Advance Payment guarantees, especially for construction or service contracts. 
  • You want to preserve your working capital and bank credit lines. 
  • You value the specialist expertise and potential project support a Surety provides. 

3. Use Trade Credit Insurance when: 

  • You need to protect against non-payment risk across multiple buyers. 
  • You want to safely offer competitive open account terms. 
  • You seek a scalable, portfolio-based credit risk management solution. 

Allianz Trade: Your Partner in Secure Trading 

Navigating these options can be complex. At Allianz Trade, we specialize in providing a comprehensive suite of risk management solutions. Our experts can help you: 

  • Understand whether a BG, Surety Bond, or TCI is the right fit for your specific needs. 
  • Access market-leading Surety and TCI products tailored to your business. 
  • Leverage our global insights and expertise to trade securely, both domestically and internationally. 

Conclusion: Navigating Risk with Confidence 

Bank Guarantees are a traditional tool for securing B2B transactions, but they are far from the only option. By understanding the distinct advantages of Surety Bonds and Trade Credit Insurance, businesses can adopt a more strategic, capital-efficient, and comprehensive approach to risk management. Allianz Trade is committed to providing the clarity and solutions you need to ensure every transaction is a confident step forward. 

Need help determining the best risk mitigation strategy for your business? Contact an Allianz Trade expert today. 

You might also like

what is trade credit insurance
What is Trade Credit Insurance?
I'm new to trade credit insurance and want to learn how it works.
Learn more
Cost of trade credit insurance
What is the cost of Trade Credit Insurance?
I want to protect my business with insurance but unsure about the cost.
See costs
Economic Insights and Risk management
Insights
Learn more about Economic & Trade Risk Insights
Learn more
Image: People discussing on a coach

Our expertise and commitment

Allianz Trade is the global leader in  trade credit insurance and  credit management, offering tailored solutions to mitigate the risks associated with bad debt, thereby ensuring the financial stability of businesses. Our products and services help companies with risk management,  cash flow management, accounts receivables protection, Surety bonds, business fraud Insurance, debt collection processes and  e-commerce credit insurance ensuring the financial resilience for our client’s businesses. Our expertise in risk mitigation and finance positions us as trusted advisors, enabling businesses aspiring for global success to expand into international markets with confidence.

Our business is built on supporting relationships between people and organizations, relationships that extend across frontiers of all kinds - geographical, financial, industrial, and more. We are constantly aware that our work has an impact on the communities we serve and that we have a duty to help and support others. At Allianz Trade, we are strongly committed to fairness for all without discrimination, among our own people and in our many relationships with those outside our business.